It’s Child Protection Week. Let’s talk about the death penalty.
Or at least talk about holding an emergency referendum on whether South Africa should reinstate capital punishment for – if nothing else – hardcore violent and violating crimes against our children, including kidnapping and trafficking.
Child Protection Week is happening at a time when the world’s spotlight is once again upon us (as if we hadn’t had enough by now) for all the wrong reasons – including the growing rampant scourge of violence and abuse against children (and women) in this country.
In just the past month South Africa has been snowed by a spate of unspeakable violent crimes against women and children, reigniting that ancient, divisive, incendiary argument and public debate on capital punishment.
And many by now are asking the big overdue question: Is it time to bring back the death penalty?
Here are just a few headlines and cases of violent crimes against children in SA that have surfaced, shocked and enraged the nation – and the world – over the past few weeks alone.
RECENT HARROWING HEADLINES
JOSLIN SMITH
Last Thursday, 29 May, the Western Cape High Court sentenced Racquel “Kelly” Smith and her two co-accused, boyfriend Jacquin “Boeta” Appollis and Steveno van Rhyn to life imprisonment and ten additional years for kidnapping and trafficking Smith’s 6-year-old daughter, Joslin.
The sentencing comes after, on 2 May this year, the court found Smith guilty of selling Joslin to a sangoma (traditional healer) for R20,000 who was interested in the child’s striking green eyes and fair complexion. (Ponder on that…)
Joslin Smith is still missing.
Of course, if by now Joslin has been (insert worst-case scenario here) Kelly Smith and her co-accused are complicit and culpable in that too.
CWECWE
The country was still reeling from the disappearance and hunt for Joslyn when the case of Cwecwe emerged and enraged the nation.
On 14 October 2024, seven-year-old “Cwecwe” was (initially) reportedly raped at her school, Bergview College, in Matatiele, Eastern Cape, while she was waiting for her transport.
Thousands of citizens and dozens of celebrities came out in support of the child. “Justice for Cwecwe” was trending.
Unfortunately, the investigation was bungled when the police authorities falsely accused the principal of the school of the crime – which led to the school being deregistered by the Eastern Cape Department of Education before an investigation was completed.
AfriForum advocate Gerrie Nel, who is representing the principal of Bergview College, believed the child was raped at a party, not at the school.
What’s further enraged the country is the fact that the investigation into Cwecwe’s case has been dropped by the National Prosecuting Authority, due to “lack of evidence”. The NPA’s announcement on 17 May that no one will be prosecuted for Cwecwe’s case has been met with sharp criticism and protests from activists and the public.
JAYDEN-LEE MEEK
On the 13 May, eleven-year-old Jayden-Lee Meek went missing after he failed to return home from school. The child’s scholar driver assured the family that Jayden was dropped off at the gates of his complex in Fleurhof, Johannesburg while his mother was working from home. Yet, he never made it inside.
The following morning, a resident discovered his lifeless, bruised and partially undressed body on a staircase in the complex, just metres from his home.
On Saturday 17 May, a large group of angry residents and community members marched to the Florida police station and handed over a memorandum of demands to officials, calling for justice and greater accountability.
SAPS Gauteng has said that its investigation into Jayden-Lee’s murder is at an advanced stage, though no arrests have been made.
Jayden-Lee Meek was laid to rest at Westpark Cemetery on Saturday 24 May 2025.
LIKHONA FOSE
Last Saturday, 31 May, 14-year-old grade 8 pupil Likhona Fose went missing from her home in Braamfischerville, Johannesburg where she lived with her grandmother. The next day, her mutilated body was discovered by a passerby in the veld at Durban Deep, Roodepoort.
Gauteng MEC Matome Chiloane dispatched trauma counsellors to Ikusasalethu, the secondary school Likhona attended. The MEC said police are “still investigating the circumstances surrounding this brutal incident” and extended sincerest condolences to the family and the school community.
KUTLWANO SHALABA
On Monday, 2 June, a 50-year-old sangoma and 32-year-old mother appeared in the Vanderbijlpark Magistrate’s Court facing charges of premeditated murder and human trafficking of the mother’s two-year-old baby, Kutlwano Shalaba.
“It is alleged that on 10 November 2024, the mother of the child (Kuneuwe Shalaba) took the child to the sangoma (Sebokoana Khounyana) and requested him to kill her child because she was not happy with the gender of the baby and was tired of hiding it from her family,” according to police.
Shalaba reportedly poisoned her child to death, the two then buried her body in a shallow grave in Waterpan.
RAPED SINCE 5, IMPREGNATED AT 11
The case against a 29-year-old man accused of raping and impregnating an 11-year-old girl resumed last month on 22 May in the Boksburg Magistrate’s Court, drawing renewed attention to a harrowing ordeal that allegedly spanned several years.
The young victim, now four months pregnant, was reportedly assaulted by the accused in December of last year. However, court proceedings revealed that the abuse may have started when the girl was just five years old, meaning the alleged crimes persisted for nearly six years before being reported.
The accused is known to the victim’s family, with the assaults allegedly taking place during visits to his home. DNA tests are yet to determine whether the suspect is indeed the perpetrator.
PAROLEE SENTENCED FOR KIDNAPPING, RAPING 9-YEAR-OLD
A shocking incident rocked Cape Town last month where a parolee, who served time for rape, has been arrested for allegedly kidnapping and raping a nine-year-old girl in Hanover Park.
On 20 May 2025, the child was found in the suspect’s house, during a frantic search by the community, where she is believed to have spent at least five hours. The accused is alleged to have lured the girl as she walked to her Madrasa (Islamic school) by offering her R20 to buy him milk and return the item to his house.
The suspect was sentenced to 25 years in jail for rape and indecent assault in 2008 but was placed on parole in November 2024.
The appalling incident has sparked fury among locals, who are demanding answers from authorities as to why a known predator was allowed back on their streets.
‘CHILDREN ARE NOT SAFE IN OUR COUNTRY’
Heard enough…? Because, plenty more where that came from. That’s just tip of the insidious iceberg, folks. And that’s just the kids.
In an article in IOL yesterday, 2 June, responding to the murders of Likhona Fose and adult victim Olerato Mongale, Jonisayi Maromo wrote; “South Africa is a dangerous place for women and girls”.
Duh, ya think!
He quoted the secretary-general of civil rights group #NotInMyName, Themba Masango, who said: “The murders of Olerato and Likhona are yet another painful reminder that South Africa remains one of the most dangerous places in the world to be a woman (or child). How many more must die before we collectively say: Enough is enough?”
Responding to the conviction of Kelly Smith in an interview with SABC News, Refilwe Mokoena (child safety and protection manager) from the Nelson Mandela Children’s Fund said: “From our perspective, justice has been served, the perpetrators have been held accountable. But children are still so vulnerable in our society and we need further preventative efforts to protect them.”
The interviewer then asked: “Can we really say that justice has been served in this regard when it comes to child safety?”
“A strong message has been sent that crimes against children will not go unpunished. But there are so many incidents similar to Joslin’s that don’t receive this level of national visibility. For every Joslin, there are millions of others we don’t even get to know about,” Mokoena answered.
(Did you catch that? She said…”millions“. If she’s right, if she’s not grossly exaggerating…then we have a BIG fu****? problem, don’tcha think?)
“Children basically are not safe in our country,” Mokoena added.
Security analyst Neil de Beer takes a slightly more radical position on how the Smith trial should’ve ended.
MAJORITY OF SA WOULD BACK DEATH PENALTY – DE BEER
In an interview with BizNews TV, former MK agent and security advisor to Nelson Mandela, De Beer (who was also peripherally involved in the police manhunt for Joslin) told journo, Chris Steyn: “What those people did to that child…if I was a judge I would unequivocally sentence them to hang.”
Visibly quivering with rage, De Beer’s eyes reddened as he teared and choked up when he said: “A child. A beautiful little girl…was sold. You took that little girl’s life, you should pay for it with your life.”
“But in this country, you don’t serve life,” he said. “In this country, if you murder, you are out in 12. You are out in eight.“
“I’m telling you, if you had a referendum on Monday, to bring back the death penalty, you’re going to get an 80% majority.”
De Beer’s not the only public figure calling for a return to capital punishment.
‘STATE MUST HAVE THE RIGHT TO KILL’ – MCKENZIE
Over the years, leader of the Patriotic Alliance (PA), Gayton McKenzie, has repeatedly called for the return of the death penalty to deal with the high level of violent crime in the country.
Back in June 2023, during an interview on The Black Pen podcast, McKenzie said: “The state must have the right to kill. People argue that the death penalty is not a deterrent. I was a criminal, and I am telling you the death penalty is a deterrent.”
He said that having been a gangster, he had learnt that taking out the leader of the gang was enough to stop gang wars.
On 17 May this year, McKenzie, who also serves as minister of Sport, Arts and Culture in the Government of National Unity (GNU), reiterated his position on the death penalty during the launch of the PA’s municipal election campaign at Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium.
Addressing a crowd of thousands of supporters with a fiery, impassioned speech, McKenzie emphasised the need for harsher punishments to combat the rising crime rates in South Africa.
“Let us bring back the death penalty. If you kill, we must kill you,” he said.
LET’S ASK A (TRUSTED) LEGAL EXPERT: JUDGE JUDY
In an interview with CNN’s Larry King in September 2009, Judge Judy Sheindlin was asked about her thoughts on the application of the death penalty.
“In a clear-cut case, where there is no issue as to whether or not, this was the perpetrator of this atrocity…I believe in my soul that it should be an option,” Sheindlin said.
Then King asked the judge: “Could you sentence someone to death?”
She paused, before replying: “Yes, I could. If…there was no question in my mind that this was the perpetrator…”
King interjected: “You could send him to his death?”
Sheindlin nodded confidently and said: “I could say…’Arrivederci’ [Italian for ‘Goodbye’].”
“There are certain people who – despite our best efforts and all of God’s good work – are wired wrong. You gotta either kill ’em or put ’em away…so that they can’t ever hurt anyone else,” she added.
TIME FOR A RED LINE ON VIOLENT CRIMES AGAINST MINORS
Must say, when it comes to hardcore violent crimes against our kids? I’m kinda leaning towards De Beer, McKenzie and Judge Judy on this one.
Maybe it is time for a long-overdue, urgent, national referendum on capital punishment for violent crimes against minors?
Never mind the special task force investigating “offensive” social media posts and misgendering online, let’s get our priorities straight…
FIRST PRIORITY OF ALL PRIORITIES: PROTECT THE KIDS!
In my perfect world, the kids would be a sacred and untouchable red line. A world where our women and children could walk down the street, in the middle of the night – bu**-naked if they so choose – and no one will harm them. Because no one would dare.
If we can unite the whole nation so easily behind a football or rugby tournament, why can’t we unite the country behind this one simple idea: protect the children, at all costs. Whatever threatens the kids…must be eliminated.
And maybe reinstating capital punishment is the only way to end the scourge of violence against minors in this country and restore some sense of safety, security and normalcy in our society, where, as Roger Waters once dreamed…
“Everyone has recourse to the law… and no one kills the children anymore.”
WHAT SAY YOU, SA? URGENT REFERENDUM ON CAPITAL PUNISHMENT FOR ULTRA-VIOLENT CRIMES AGAINST MINORS?
Let us know by leaving a comment below or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1.
Subscribe to The South African website’s newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
