LOVE Island All Stars winners Casey O’Gorman and Gabby Allen have fuelled a secret feud involving their fellow finalists by going on ‘a double date’.
Casey and Gabby proudly posed for a picture with winning alumni Tom Clare and Molly Smith after finally getting together for a much-discussed dinner.
But they also asked along ex islander Mitchel Taylor and his girlfriend Hayley Griffin – and it has not gone down well with Luca Bish and Grace Jackson.
Mitch was accused of “sabotaging” Luca and Grace’s efforts to win Love Island All Stars by spreading so-called ‘texts from Grace’.
In an explosive on-screen clash, Liv Hawkins claimed Grace had messaged another islander before heading into the villa, saying she’d “do anything to win”.
Mitch – aka Messy Mitch – went on to circulate what appeared to be the Snapchat messages between Grace and a mystery pal.
The mystery friend said: “You’re my winner regardless.”
‘Grace’ replied: “Aww thank you babe. I will win this time. I’ll do anything.”
However, in a live with fans, Mitch later admitted the messages “could be fake”.
But the damage was done, with fans claiming Luca and Grace missed out on the £50,000 prize pot because of the controversy.
Casey and Gabby’s win came as a surprise to viewers of the ITV2 show and they have now met with Mitch at celebrity hangout Sheesh.
Despite calling it a “double date” with Love Island All Stars 2024 winners Tom and Molly, Mitch was also snapped with them at the London restaurant – along with a group of family and friends.
Sharing snaps and a video on Instagram, Tom said: “The double date happened… well kinda, surprised by their Family & Friends too, big love.”
Gabby replied: “Such a special night! Thank you Tom xx.”
Casey added: “A best friend anyone could ever dream of. Thanks for organising the best night ever.”
All fans wanted to discuss, however, was the fact Luca and Grace had not liked Tom’s social media post with Mitch in.
Sharing their opinion on the scandal, one follower said: “Hanging with the guy that sabotaged Grace .. so you’d win the show i see.. Grace & Luca are the real winners.”
Another added: “Obviously Mitch was there, he was the reason you won.”
And a third said: “He knew it was fake, he even said it on a live. That wasn’t fair.”
Luca was said to be “fuming” he and Grace had not won Love Island All Stars.
Love Island winners - where they are now
EVERY year Love Island opens its doors to more sexy Islanders who are hoping for a holiday romance that could turn into more.
Here we take you through all of the Love Island winners so far and what their relationship statuses are now:
2025 – The second series of All Stars saw Gabby Allen and Case O’Gorman scoop the crown. STATUS: Still together.
2024 – The summer Love Island saw Mimii Ngulube and Josh Oyinsan were crowned the winners. STATUS: Broken up.
2024 – The first ever All stars spin off show was won by Molly Smith and Tom Clare. STATUS: Still together.
2023 – Jess Harding and Sammy Root took home the 50k, and won the summer 2023 Love Island. STATUS: Broken up.
2023 – The first series of 2023 saw Sanam Harrinanan and Kai Fagan crowned Love Island winners in South Africa. STATUS: Still together.
2022 – Davide Sanclimenti and Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu’s time in the villa was anything but a smooth ride, but they managed to win the public’s hearts – and the ITV2 reality show. STATUS: Broken up.
2021 – Liam Reardon and Millie Court were announced winners of Love Island 2021. STATUS: Still together.
2020 – The first ever winter Love Island saw Paige Turley and Finn Tapp crowned winners after falling in love on the show. STATUS: Broken up.
2019 – Series 5 saw Tommy Fury and Molly-Mae Hague runners up to winners Greg O’Shea and Amber Gill, who met in the last few days of the series. STATUS: Broken up.
2018 – It wasn’t surprising fan favourites Jack Fincham and Dani Dyer won the show, as they were strong throughout. But sadly things didn’t last. STATUS: Broken up.
2017 – Kem Cetinay and Amber Davies had lots of ups and downs in the villa but went on to win. STATUS: Broken up.
2016 – Nathan Massey and Cara De La Hoyde were together from the start of the series, and since they won the show they’ve had two kids and are married. STATUS: Still together.
2015 – Despite poor Jess Hayes being Max Morley’s second choice on the show, they did win – but they didn’t last as a couple. STATUS: Broken up.
The couple finished in second place, despite bookies’ William Hill having them down as the front-runners.
Luca and Grace filmed a ‘thank you’ speech for the official Love Island social media accounts, but fans accused him of failing to hide his true feelings.
In the tense video, the runner-up said: “Honestly, it’s been the best journey and we couldn’t have done it without you guys.
“Thanks for voting, thanks for everything you guys have done.”
Picking up on his less than chipper attitude, one fan replied: “I’d be fuming too if i got second place twice.”
A second mused: “Luca looks FUMING,” as a third agreed and put: “I just know Grace and Luca are fuming they will be over before Easter.”
Luca and Grace shrugged off Casey and Gabby’s celebratory meal on by going on their own date elsewhere this week.
On Sunday night, the couple were snapped together looking cosy as they sipped on cocktails at a different restaurant.
